Background - Last Friday I attended the Northern Virginia Technology Council (NVTC ) meeting where all four of Virginia’s gubernatorial candidates met. The format was one four minute speech with the other three candidates on stage. Then, three of the four candidates left the stage (and were presumably transported out of earshot). One candidate faced the crowd and answered 3 sets of questions in broad categories. The order of the four minute speeches and the order that the candidates faced the Q&A sessions were drawn by lot. The question categories were the same for each candidate. However, the questions were all from the audience and differed from one candidate to the next. Each candidate had 7 minutes to answer audience questions asked in each of the three categories. So, each candidate spoke or answered questions for 25 minutes (4 minute speech + three 7 minute Q&A sessions). All in all I thought the session was brilliantly organized and well run. My personal thanks go out to the NVTC and the host for the session – Microsoft.
First Impressions
Swimsuit Contest- The four candidates were Republican Bob McDonnell (Attorney General, Va Beach), Rep. Brian Moran (D, Springfield), Sen. Creigh Deeds (D, Bath County) and Terry McAulliffe (D, McLean). The three Democrats will face each other in a primary to be held on June 9. Mr. McDonnell is running unopposed for the Republican nomination and will almost certainly be the Republican nominee for the November race.
Creigh (pronounced Cree) Deeds seemed nervous. He jesticulated too much. He seemed like a guy someone told to emphasize his statements with hand jestures. However, he also exuded honesty and believability. He came across as a genuinely nice man and his southern Virginia accent was the only accent in the bunch that was consistent (more on that later). During his four minute speech Sen. Deeds emphasized his experience citing his 22 years of leadership.
Terry McAulliffe came across as over-animated as well. He had a bit of the nerdy political junkie thing going. His opening remarks revolved around the theme that “not all good ideas come from Richmond.”. He established himself as a successful businessman who had turned around a number of struggling companies and made them successes. He portrayed himself as a blue collar kid who made it big and an outsider to Virginia politics.
Bob McDonnell was the smooth politician who was witty one minute and steely the next. He talked about growing up in Fairfax County (where his mother still lives in the house where he grew up), his career in the US Army and his tenure as Attorney General. He spoke with the ambiguous accent of many Northern Virginians.
Brian Moran was tall and had something of the stand up comic in his presentation. He talked about his 20 years of service, his family, awards he has gotten and how he sees himself as a legacy of Mark Warner and Tim Kaine. He was the consummate Virginia Democrat. Unfortunately, he had some of the smirky facial expressions of a college frat boy. He also tried to lay on a southern facade with a few y’alls but was given away by his almost genetic Boston accent.
Bob McDonnell made the best first impression followed by McAulliffe, Deeds and then Moran.
Details
Brian Moran
Moran started with a sing song discussion of ”Galax to Fairfax”. He invoked memories of Mark Warner and Tim Kaine repeatedly. He discussed his trip to India and the importance of Virginia being competitive not just against other states but on the global stage as well. He talked generically about transportation and the quality of life in Virginia. Finally, he talked about his family – Congressman Jim Moran and his brother who works for Microsoft (and was in the audience).
Bob McDonnell
AG McDonnell began by noting that Fairfax County had the highest concentration of technology workers in Virginia. He talked about his time as Attorney General and how he worked with Gov. Kaine to protect kids on the Internet. He talked about economic development in Virginia and spoke of making Virginia a hub for film production and tourism. He said he’d cut the red tape required to get a film shoot approved in Virginia and make Virginia the energy capital of America with a combination of clean coal, nuclear, offshore drilling and alternate energy. He supported Virginia’s right to work laws and spoke against the card check law. He hoped that the national government would avoid protectionist legislation. He declared immigration to be a federal issue although he wanted to increase the number of legal immigrants holding visas for technology and scientiific skills. He supports charter schools and Rail To Dulles. He wants to widen I-66 and believes in the Rt 460 – Craney (sp?) port project in Tidewater.
Sen. Deeds
Sen. Deeds noted that unemployment in Virginia is higher than it has been in 17 years. He is dedicated to job creation – especially in energy based research. He favors an expanded community college system. He wants to continue many of the policies of the Warner Administration. He says we must face the transportation issue and may have to discuss “revenue” as part of that challenge. He dislikes the modern day approach of pitting one part of Virginia against another. He’d like to connect communities with broadband internet.
Terry McAulliffe
Mr. McAulliffe began by rattling off a number of unemployment statistics in Virginia such as Martinsville at 20.2%. He stressed his interest in creating jobs in the Commonwealth saying that he would get stimulus money from the federal government and would personally go from company to company trying to convince the companies to relocate to Virginia. He declared transportation to be a mess and said we need more roads. He reminded those who say that they don’t want to pay for NoVa roads that NoVa probably doesn’t want to pay for other regions’ schools. He promised to dillute the Dillon Rule. He talked about the year 2018 as the year Virginia will no longer qualify for federal matching funds in transportation since we are underfunding our own transportation system. He put forth the idea of commercializing the patents being developed at Virginia universities citing the $500 per year that Florida gains from this practice.
Summary
I have not decided who I will support. This was a good introductory meeting but was far from a debate on the issues of the day. I think any of the four men would make good governors with the possible exception of Brian Moran who just didn’t seem all that serious about the issues.